Hacker GitHub

← All repos

christianbundy/octotree

View on GitHub ↗ ★ 5 JavaScript

13 mentions on Hacker News by 9 people: 1 story, 12 comments · first 2020-10-31 · latest 2020-12-08

Mentions per year 13 mentions · busiest year 2020 (13)
20082026
AllStoriesComments NewestTopOldest
  1. …lides.com/adamretter/are-we-still-open-source [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24953821 [2]: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1
    comment by j1elo · 2020-12-08 · in We Love GPLv3, but Are Switching License to Apache 2.0
  2. https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by deng · 2020-11-01 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  3. And from the latest comment on this issue ( https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom... ): It seems that the project switched from MIT to AGPL around 2016, so all the contributor commits before that doesn't matter.…
    comment by logimame · 2020-11-01 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  4. …They apologized for being dismissive, thanked people, and discussion has become much more civil. https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by jml7c5 · 2020-11-01 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  5. …the case, not trying to suggest he should do something, just checking my understanding.) [0] - https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by OJFord · 2020-11-01 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  6. They have now reverted to AGPL. I'm glad they didn't decide to die on that hill. https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by gilrain · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  7. …with 30 LOC, one with 10 LOC, and the remaining 12 contributors average less then 4 LOC each. [1] https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by ckastner · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  8. …lie. The minified JavaScript has tons of 1:1 copies of the AGPL code, clear as day (example: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom... ), and the maintainer is deleting any comment that mentions the clear evidence.
    comment by jhardy54 · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  9. Yep, lots of them are still the most recent author according to git-blame too: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
    comment by jhardy54 · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  10. …intertwined with the current codebase, which is a derivative of those contributions. Example: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom... If the maintainer wants to remove the AGPL without copyright infringement, I…
    comment by jhardy54 · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  11. …informative now that the maintainer nuked the thread. :/ I've started a new GH discussion here: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1
    comment by jhardy54 · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  12. …has decided to suppress this conversation via censorship, I thought I'd move the discussion here." https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1
    comment by CharlesW · 2020-10-31 · in Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
  13. ▲ 332
    Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
    story by jhardy54 · 2020-10-31 · 249 comments